PDA

View Full Version : Chicago's soda tax repealed, in blow to 'nanny-state crusade'



Teh One Who Knocks
10-12-2017, 11:14 AM
By Sarah Smith, Fox News


https://i.imgur.com/rSmXCa5.jpg

The Cook County Board voted Wednesday to repeal the Chicago-area county’s controversial soda tax, after a public backlash to the penny-per-ounce charge.

Low-tax advocates cheered the decision as a blow to the “nanny-state crusade.” Cook County, which includes Chicago, was the largest jurisdiction in the country with a soda tax.

"If there is one city America's tax and spenders should be able muscle through the latest tax fad, it would be Chicago. And yet in this tax and spend, Democrat-run city, consumers forced the city council to cough up their recent tax hike and repeal the soda tax," Grover Norquist, president of the anti-tax Americans for Tax Reform, said in a statement.

Wednesday’s vote would nix the soda tax -- which only recently went into effect -- by December.

Proponents of the tax claimed it would improve public health by discouraging the purchase of sugary drinks, which have been connected to health issues like obesity and Type 2 diabetes.

But critics argued it hurt retailers and hit low-income residents particularly hard.

“Nothing good has come from Cook County’s beverage tax. Residents and consumers have been forced to pay more on over 1,000 everyday beverages, including diet drinks,” the anti-tax Can the Tax Coalition said in a statement on its website.

After delays related to a lawsuit from the Illinois Retail Merchants Association, the tax on sugary beverages went into effect this past August.

David Goldenberg, a spokesman for the anti-tax coalition, told Fox News that one problem with the tax was that similar beverages would be treated differently depending on how they were packaged. For instance, he said, a sweet bottled drink would be taxed while a similar beverage from a barista would be exempt.

“It had nothing to do with health -- everything to do with revenue” Goldenberg said.

The Chicago Tribune reported that the American Beverage Association and store owners spent millions pushing for repeal, while soda tax crusader Michael Bloomberg backed an even more expensive ad campaign to preserve the tax.

Revenue was a factor. In her 2018 budget address last week, Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle, a supporter of the soda tax, reportedly argued that an estimated $200 million a year from the tax would help avoid budget cuts.

RBP
10-12-2017, 12:55 PM
It was nothing but a pure money grab and pushed business out of Cook County. I have just been buying in other counties.

There was no health issue here, that was smoke and mirrors, especially considering that those using SNAP don't pay the tax.

Teh One Who Knocks
10-12-2017, 01:02 PM
Revenue was a factor. In her 2018 budget address last week, Cook County Board President Toni Preckwinkle, a supporter of the soda tax, reportedly argued that an estimated $200 million a year from the tax would help avoid budget cuts.

This is something that always pisses me off. Hey, Mr Taxpayer, if we don't get more money, we'll have to cut the budget and that means firemen and policemen and schools, so give us the money! How about the cities be forced to do what every American has to do? Get bids/quotes on things. Does what you're paying right now seem excessive? Then shop around, that's what normal people that HAVE to live within a budget do. Keep your 'budget cut' threats to yourselves and do your damn job and represent the taxpayers.

/rant

RBP
10-12-2017, 01:04 PM
This is something that always pisses me off. Hey, Mr Taxpayer, if we don't get more money, we'll have to cut the budget and that means firemen and policemen and schools, so give us the money! How about the cities be forced to do what every American has to do? Get bids/quotes on things. Does what you're paying right now seem excessive? Then shop around, that's what normal people that HAVE to live within a budget do. Keep your 'budget cut' threats to yourselves and do your damn job and represent the taxpayers.

/rant

:qft:

Drunken sailors with an open bar tab.

Teh One Who Knocks
10-12-2017, 01:14 PM
Exactly, and it baffles me why no one has ever desired to change the system. If we are paying too much for insurance, we shop around. Same with mortgage rates, bank fees, groceries, contractors, car repairs...every person does it because they don't have the option of magically generating more money by stealing it from people that work for a living. And notice that it's always those same three things they say are going to lose funding in budget cuts? It's always the fire department, police department, and schools, because that plays on everyone's fears. It's ridiculous.

Hopefully having Trump in the White House will trickle down and get more business savvy people into government.

RBP
10-12-2017, 01:17 PM
Exactly, and it baffles me why no one has ever desired to change the system. If we are paying too much for insurance, we shop around. Same with mortgage rates, bank fees, groceries, contractors, car repairs...every person does it because they don't have the option of magically generating more money by stealing it from people that work for a living. And notice that it's always those same three things they say are going to lose funding in budget cuts? It's always the fire department, police department, and schools, because that plays on everyone's fears. It's ridiculous.

Hopefully having Trump in the White House will trickle down and get more business savvy people into government.

A far left family member told me that "once they give something they can't just take it away". I replied, "I hope it doesn't work that way or we're all in deep shit".

PorkChopSandwiches
10-12-2017, 03:56 PM
I cant wait until we pay 90% of our earnings in taxes

RBP
10-12-2017, 06:51 PM
I cant wait until we pay 90% of our earnings in taxesMarginal rates were close under Carter. But even if we did, they would still spend more than that.

PorkChopSandwiches
10-12-2017, 06:58 PM
that is true

DemonGeminiX
10-12-2017, 07:02 PM
And in other news, dentists flock to Chicago to open up businesses... :face: