PDA

View Full Version : Girl, 12, ends life to donate eyes to dad, kidney to brother; last wishes found in note -- after she was cremated...



AntZ
07-07-2011, 06:14 PM
Girl ends life to donate eyes to dad

Ashis Poddar, TNN

Jul 4, 2011, 12.15am IST




NADIA: For days, Mumpy would listen quietly as the elders discussed how only an eye surgery could save her father's vision and a kidney transplant her brother's life. But both surgeries were beyond the family's meagre means. So, Mumpy hit upon a plan, which to her 12-year-old mind seemed the answer to all troubles. She would kill herself, which would save the dowry, too, and her organs would give her loved ones back their lives.

Mumpy did stick to her plan. But the suicide note in which she had scribbled down her wishes was found the day after she was cremated.

The incident took place in Dhantala's Jhorpara on June 27. Her father's and brother's ailments had left Mumpy Sarkar, a Class VI student, anxious. One of the kidneys of her brother Monojit, a Class XI student, was damaged and the other was getting weak. Father Mridul Sarkar, a daily wager, was also gradually losing his eyesight.

"The family had approached the local MLA for help. We had decided to grant them some money for the boy's treatment. But the tragedy happened all of a sudden," said Dhantala panchayat pradhan Tapas Tarafdar.

Mumpy had taken elder sister Monica, a Class VIII student, into confidence and had urged her to commit suicide as well for the "cause". When Mumpy told Monica about her plan on the morning of June 27, the latter laughed it off and left for school. Their father was away at work and mother Rita had gone to fetch rice.

"Finding herself alone at home, Mumpy consumed Thiodan, a pesticide. Then, she ran to meet her father, who was about half a kilometre away. She told him that she had dreamt that someone had poured poison into her mouth and her stomach ached. Her alarmed father took her to a local pharmacy immediately where she was given some medicines. But her condition worsened soon and she had to be rushed to the local Baranberia hospital. From there, she was referred to Anulia hospital. But the doctors declared her brought dead," Tarafdar said.

It was only the day after her cremation that Mumpy's father found a note on her bed. Addressed to her mother, the girl requested her to make use of her eyes and kidney for the treatment of her father and brother. This left the aggrieved family inconsolable. "We were too late in understanding the feelings of a very sensitive child," Mridul wept. Mumpy's mother has gone into shock.


http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2011-07-04/india/29735331_1_kidney-transplant-eye-surgery-girl-ends-life

Muddy
07-07-2011, 06:26 PM
Man this is so fucked up, I wouldn't have even posted it...

AntZ
07-07-2011, 06:30 PM
Man this is so fucked up, I wouldn't have even posted it...

But in India the people have a much different belief system, if it had not been for the lost note, she would be honored right now??


If there was ever a use for the EPIC FAIL icon, it's this story here!

Hal-9000
07-07-2011, 06:30 PM
I'm looking at a 60 something East Indian co-worker.His son was on dialysis for years and 2 weeks ago, got a kidney transplant....from his new wife.They were married last year.

That to me, is the ultimate sacrifice :thumbsup: Both are doing well and of course my joke to the father now is - I hope your son doesn't get divorced,
she may ask for the kidney back in the settlement.

DemonGeminiX
07-07-2011, 07:27 PM
Oh man, this story is awful.

Deepsepia
07-07-2011, 07:45 PM
Oh man, this story is awful.

Fortunately, its probably not true.

This is supposed to have occurred in a very rural primitive part of India, West Bengal, borders Bangladesh.

Notice that there's all kinds of "first person" quotes, but not a single authority. No doctor, no policeman, no reference to any official document.

Its not impossible that its true, but when you see first person reporting -- which requires that a reporter actually have talked to someone, and you don't see any other signs of a reporter at work (eg "spoke with Detective Inspector Ramesh" or "according to Dr. Pal") then the index of suspicion should be high

Muddy
07-07-2011, 08:07 PM
What kinda scam is this Antz ??!!:villagers::villagers::villagers::villagers:

DemonGeminiX
07-07-2011, 08:09 PM
It's not just Antz. It seems like every single website is running this story.

Google "Girl ends life to donate eyes to dad". It's all over the place.

Muddy
07-07-2011, 08:12 PM
Im just razzing him...

DemonGeminiX
07-07-2011, 08:14 PM
Oh, I know, but it's unbelievable how this story is all over the place.

Deepsepia
07-07-2011, 08:18 PM
Oh, I know, but it's unbelievable how this story is all over the place.

When stories come out of places you don't know, you don't have any of the instincts that you'd have about a story from the States. When you see a weird story from some place you've never heard of, being reported someplace you know nothing about, skepticism should be your first instinct. Again, its not impossible that its true . . . but then its not impossible that this is true, either:

http://picload.org/image/ligipi/hillaryalien.jpg

Muddy
07-07-2011, 08:23 PM
When stories come out of places you don't know, you don't have any of the instincts that you'd have about a story from the States. When you see a weird story from some place you've never heard of, being reported someplace you know nothing about, skepticism should be your first instinct. Again, its not impossible that its true . . . but then its not impossible that this is true, either:

http://picload.org/image/ligipi/hillaryalien.jpg

Is that thing reaching in to breast feed a titty?

Deepsepia
07-07-2011, 08:29 PM
Is that thing reaching in to breast feed a titty?

Got it

http://picload.org/image/ligpdd/hillary_clinton.jpg